All of CIFOR's research programs are developing and applying participatory and/or participatory action research in combination with more traditional research approaches and using some gender and/or diversity-oriented analysis.
Some of CIFOR's gender and diversity-related lessons, such as linkages between policies and gender in the management of miombo woodlands of southern Africa, are brought together in our recent books on communities, equity and diversity.
In Asia CIMMYT uses quick and inexpensive participatory rural appraisal techniques to ensure that the problems of maize farmers in marginal areas are brought to the attention of researchers. In Zimbabwe, Mother-Baby trials have created a forum where farmers and researchers communiate about the kind of maize seed farmers need. Although participatory plant breeding (PPB) is gaining greater acceptance worldwide, the techniques needed to analyze the data from participatory methodologies in the context of plant breeding are still not well known or understood. In 2002, CIMMYT organized a workshop on Quantitative Analysis of Data from Participatory Methods in Plant Breeding. The papers presented address the three themes: designing and analyzing joint experiments involving variety evaluation by farmers; identifying and analyzing farmers' evaluations of crop characteristics and varieties; and dealing with social heterogeneity and other research issues. Topics covered included different statistical methodologies for analyzing data from on-farm trials; the mother-baby trial system, evaluation of maize landraces by small-scale farmers; and a PPB process that aims to address the difficulties of setting breeding goals and choosing parents in diversity research studies.
A participatory research working group (PRWG) has been active at CIP since 2000 with the aim of promoting participatory research within the Center. Activities include internal workshops about participatory research methods, supporting individual researchers interested in participatory research, establishing contacts with external resource institutions, and, recently the group launched an electronic bulletin with news about participatory research at CIP, useful references and discussion topics. As a result of the activities of the PRWG and the interest of CIP's researchers and management, participatory research activities have been formally included in the structure of research projects such as "Integrated Management of Late Blight" and "Integrated pest management for root and tuber crops". Within these projects, funding has been obtained to conduct participatory research related to these issues. Examples include a grant provided by the International Fund for Agricultural Research (IFAD) to adapt the farmer field school (FFS) approach to work on potato-related problems, and to conduct comparative studies among participatory methods. The contribution of participatory research to CIP's work has been recognised in visioning and strategic planning exercises conducted since 2000. As a result participatory research is considered as an important activity at least in two of CIP's new Research Divisions. These are: Germplasm Enhancement and Crop Improvement, and Integrated Crop Management. CIP also hosts Users' Perspectives With Agricultural Research and Development (UPWARD), a network of scientists and development specialists working to increase participation by farmers and other users of agricultural technology in research and development. UPWARD addresses three important challenges facing agricultural research and development today: linking users and R&D professionals for more effective agricultural innovation; bringing sustained benefits to less favored farming areas and marginalized groups, especially women; and working with households and local communities as key actors in problem diagnosis and research activities.
In ICARDA's Participatory Plant Breeding Program farmers and researchers work together to develop new new varieties. Decentralized selection, defined as selection in the target environment, has been used by ICARDA's barley breeding program to avoid the risk of useful lines being discarded because of their relatively poor performance at the experiment stations. Decentralized selection is a powerful methodology to fit crops to the physical (climate and management) environment. However, crop breeding based on decentralized selection can still miss its objectives if it does not utilize the farmers' knowledge of the crops and the environment, and it may fail to fit crops to the specific needs and uses of farmers communities unless it becomes participatory. Participation of farmers in the very initial stages of breeding, when the large genetic variability created by the breeders is virtually untapped, is expected to exploit fully the potential gains from breeding for specific adaptation through decentralized selection by adding farmer's perception of their own needs and farmers' knowledge of the crop.
In 2002 the World Fish Center organized a Global Symposium on Women in fisheries. This Symposium raised several issues including community involvement in fisheries, and the vulnerability of fishers and their families to HIV/AIDS. The next logical step is to move towards gender and fisheries, so that the constraints and inequity among men and women may be better understood, and recommendations made to overcome the inequity. The Center's Policy Research and Impact Program examines policy environment and options in fisheries, aquaculture and coastal and freshwater resources management to ensure wider adoption and benefits of research by the poor in the developing world. An intermediate goal of the program is management of aquatic resources in a sustainable, equitable and participatory manner.
Researchers and farmers are seeking to diversify fodder sources, by testing fodder shrubs and herbaceous legumes as part of the World Agroforestry Center's strategy of doing science with farmers.
Functional linkages between research, extension, farmers and markets and participatory approaches enhance the impact of knowledge and technologies generated through ICRISAT's research on food insecurity and poverty. For feedback from farmers click HERE.
IFRI's research program on Gender and Intrahousehold Aspects of Food Policy generates information for the development of policies, programs, and projects that take into account intrahousehold resource allocation processes. Research on Genetic Resources, undertaken collaboratively with IPGRI, uses participatory research to examine incentives and policies for local conservation of agrobiodiversity. IFPRI also hosts the CGIAR's Systemwide Program on Collective Action and Property Rights.
International Service for National Agricultural Research (ISNAR): Research over the past decades has increasingly pointed to the importance of gender issues in agricultural development. ISNAR's project on Gender Relations in Agricultural Research explores the role of gender issues in agricultural research policy, management, and organization.
Pilot sites for testing by farmers of "best bet" IPM options, based on the research of participating International Agricultural Research Centers and numerous partner organizations, have been established in contrasting agroecological zones across Africa in Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Egypt, Kenya, Morocco, and Nigeria.
ILRI and the PRGA cosponsored a capacity-building workshop on Participatory research for productivity enhancement of smallholder ruminant livestock systems
IPGRI's program on Livelihoods and Institutions focuses on the various ways people use and value genetic resources and how this affects their conservation. Socioeconomic and cultural factors which govern variation within and across communities, especially gender, need to be taken into account when designing conservation strategies for plant genetic resources. There are two main objectives:
The program has developed tools for participatory research on crop and tree diversity, contributed to the development of participatory plant breeding and gender-sensitive use and conservation of plant genetic resources.
The Poverty Elimination through Rice Research Assistance (PETRRA) is a five-year project funded by the UK's Department for International Development and managed by the Philippines-based International Rice Research Institute, in close partnership with the Bangladesh Rice Research Institute (BRRI), the Bangladesh Ministry of Agriculture, and most importantly the resource poor rice farmers of Bangladesh. The purpose of the PETRRA Project is to increase productivity of rice based farming systems for resource poor farmers sustainably in order to contribute to poverty elimination. The project will achieve its purpose by facilitating the development of a demand-led research system.The central focus of PETRRA is resource-poor farm households (RPFs) considering both men and women. For this PETRRA strives for best practice in participation, partnership, critique and openness, poverty focus, gender sensitivity and environmental awareness. The project is committed to decentralization. PETRRA strategy has six pillars: targeting resource-poor farm households; gender-sensitivity; environmental awareness; focal areas for project activities; farmers' participation in setting research priorities and technology development; and research themes that link technology and uptake.
IWMI has conducted research on gender and irrigation and Integrated Water Resources Management or more than a decade. Gender research is especially prominent in IWMI's Themes on Smallholder Land and Water Management Systems and Water Resources Institutions and Policies in Africa and India. Through its Smallholder Livelihoods theme, IWMI is identifying promising land and water management innovations suitable for very poor people, evaluating them with partners to understand how they work, their impacts, how they can be adapted, and how their uptake can be promoted. A gender-inclusive action-research project has been started under the CGIAR Challenge Program on Water and Food entitled 'Models for implementing multiple-use water supply systems for enhanced land and water productivity, rural livelihoods, and gender equity'. In this project, research institutes collaborate with local communities and implementing NGOs at global and national levels, especially for testing new self-financed water supply systems for both domestic and productive uses. IWMI also collaborates with the Gender and Water Alliance to ensure gender mainstreaming within the Global Water Partnership and other partners committed to Integrated Water Resources Management.
Farmers are partners with scientists in the tailoring of rice varieties to suit their own needs. This partly explains why new rices for Africa are spreading rapidly across the region. WARDA has learned that technology spreads more quickly, with more impact, if farmers have an input early in its development
AHI's research focuses on key natural resource management and agricultural productivity issues in the intensively cultivated highlands of East and Central Africa. Concerned National Agricultural Reseach Institutes (NARIs), International Agricultural Research Centres (IARCs) and various NGOs are collaborating to improve research and development approaches and partnerships to develop and institutionalize effective and efficient approaches for sustainable integrated natural resource management (INRM) and enhanced productivity. AHI was started by ASARECA in 1995 and is hosted by the World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF). AHI is promoting integrated, inter-institutional research and development efforts with strong community participation to solve critical issues of soil productivity, water and land-use. AHI's mandate and role in ASARECA portfolio is to develop, promote and use an INRM approach for improving development strategies, practices and policies (more information...).
The CGIAR System-wide Program on Collective Action and Property Rights (CAPRi) examines factors that influence collective action for a range of activities that communities might undertake that contribute to poverty reduction. An edited volume on Innovation in Natural Resource Management presents a conceptual framework and case studies. Much of the focus has been on studies of natural resource management, but many of these same issues apply to group formation and functioning for participatory research. A workshop on Methods for Studying Collective Action provides a number of approaches and factors that affect collective action, as well as case studies of participatory research. A workshop on Watershed Management addressed the role of property rights and collective action in watershed management, including many participatory research projects. Ongoing research and a recent workshop on the role local management of genetic resources deals with the role of collective action and property rights over "partner resources" (land and water) in influencing conservation of genetic resources, as well as how different approaches to intellectual property rights can influence farmers' and breeders' ability and incentives to develop new varieties.
The purpose of the Gender and Diversity Program is to help the Future Harvest Centers of the CGIAR leverage their rich staff diversity to increase research and management excellence. G&D promotes such activities as diversity-positive recruitment, international teamwork, cross-cultural communications and advancement for women. Its website features a popular series of working papers, a cybrary of best links, a special section on diversity in virtual teams, and the opportunity to sign up to its newsletter and database of women scientists.
Copyright © Participatory Research and Gender Analysis 2003-2005. All rights reserved.
The PRGA gratefully acknowledges the support of Bellanet, CIAT and Juliana Aristizábal in the development of this website.